Showing posts with label unionist. Show all posts
Showing posts with label unionist. Show all posts

Thursday, 13 February 2014

Opportunities (Let's Make Lots Of Money)

Phil Lawrence, Tallinn, 13th February 2014

So it’s official. All the Queen’s horses and all the Queen’s men have decided that Humpty Dumpty (AKA Oor Eck) should have a great fall and unlike in the nursery rhyme they will be the perpetrators, not those rushing to the aid of the afflicted. Gideon, Edward and Danny have closed ranks and decided that we are not worthy of continued use of our own currency.

Giddy George delivered his message today with relish and a self-satisfied smirk as his blood brothers from the other Unionist parties regurgitated potted versions on his theme.

Barely had the hot air subsided when no less a figure than the Research Director of the esteemed Adam Smith Institute, Sam Bowman, was waxing lyrical on the benefits of using the currency without formal agreement pointing out that, “An independent Scotland that used the pound as its base currency without the English government’s permission, with banks continuing to issue notes privately and private citizens free to choose any currency they wanted, would probably have a more stable financial system and economy than England itself.”

Bowman then noted, “It’s up to Scots to decide whether they want independence, but the Chancellor’s announcement today should be seen as a feature, not a bug.”

What? Wow! That wasn’t in the script! Who are these upstart Adam Smith chappies? Well they just happen to be the Libertarian think tank that largely sculpted a great deal of Thatcherism, especially in privatization policy, and a big chunk of Tony Blair’s populism. OK, that’s not the best recommendation north of the border but if one thing’s for sure it’s that the Adam Smith Institute knows what will fly and what won’t.

So we should have the pound without the benefit of policy input. It’s the same way that some Latin American countries use the US dollar and a number of European states outside the EU have adopted the euro.

This is a good option for any country looking for short- to medium-term stability WITHOUT having to spend in shoring up the value of the currency. If there is a run on sterling – and there will be – then Scotland can detach itself without drama or fanfare and then our commodity-backed currency (Scottish Crown, Merk, Pound or whatever) will find its own par at the inevitable higher level. Look out NOK!

I just always saw the currency union as a bit like Devo-Max – a halfway house measure that was neither fish nor fowl. I'm not unhappy to see it being undermined but I suspect that this may have been the idea all along... You have to smoke out the objections as early as possible.

Along the way several major Yes policy announcements have stunk to high heaven from my standpoint but they have been seen to be tactical markers thrown down that Project Fear should skip around. Of course they don’t do that and just steam right through the middle thereby proving that Bitter the Gither is completely reactive with not one proactive notion in their combined head. They don’t predict, they only lash out. They don’t get subtlety and can only bludgeon. That’s ideal for Yes as they can set the agenda. 

Even subliminally?

Consider this. It is only in recent weeks that the Yes campaign has ramped up currency union as probably the prime issue. Was this all about timing? Was this designed to get the Unionists fixated on the Sterling Zone and cause them to shoot their bolt? Alex Salmond is not just the best parliamentary debater alive in the entire UK today, he is probably the best long-term strategist as well.

The more I think about it the more I hear the playground chant, “You fell for it! You fell for it!” Did Gideon et al fall for it? I’m inclined to suggest that this may be the case.

In some more smoke and mirrors I also can imagine that what we saw today was pounced upon by the Unionists for another altogether different purpose. I smell a rat and his name is Nigel. This is not just all about Scotland. The Establishment is closing ranks to save their skins in England. This is designed to appeal to Middle England as UKIP look likely to win the Euro elections in 3 months time. It seems directed at one audience but resonates with another. Tactically, at face value it might be regarded by some as smart. Strategically it is a disaster.

Am I giving Oor Eck too much credit? Did the stars just align themselves all on their own? Or was there a wee boost somewhere?

So at the end of today where do we stand? The Unionists have probably been enticed to blink way, way, way too early with the Adam Smith Institute – one of the leading free market research establishments on the planet – patting Scotland on the back. Add to that the previously stated view of the US Federal Reserve on “borrowing” a currency being that we will, “consequentially have far more prudent and stable financial systems than if they were part of a formal currency union.”

All in all not too bad when the media were waiting for Gideon to tap in his open goal. Hmmm, maybe cricket’s his game. Or maybe he’s a wet bob? (That’s public school jargon for a rower, don’t you know?)

I am inclined to believe that Eck is less Humpty Dumpty and more Little Jack Horner – he put in his thumb, and pulled out a plum!

--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

All the cloak and dagger stuff in the past 48 hours has made me think again and again of card-playing analogies. Here’s a few commonly used terms and how they apply today:

George Osborne – the Dealer (who oddly lays all his own cards out face-up!!!)
Ed Balls – the perennial Joker
Danny Alexander – the Busted Flush
Perm any 2 from those 3 – a Low Pair

Alex Salmond – Full House

Sunday, 4 December 2011

Taxing Times

Friday's Scotsman includes a remarkably blinkered critique of the Scotland Bill and Holyrood’s opposition to the lack of tax-raising powers incorporated therein with particular emphasis to Corporation Tax by Graham Gudgin. 


Dr. Gudgin is certainly something of an expert in Stormont affairs and is held in some high regard for that but his assertions that what is good for Northern Ireland will be detrimental for Scotland are based on some rather tenuous premises that do not stand up to anything like close scrutiny and finally fall into the category of Unionism for its own sake. That may be all well and good working on an agenda pushed by Peter Robinson and the DUP but that is nothing like the same dynamic that drives the SNP’s desire for fiscal powers.

He takes the view that for every 1% cut in the rate there would be a loss of 2,000 public sector jobs. He also takes the view that this reduction would create new private sector jobs at a net rate of 500 per year per 1% but doubts where the funding income gap might be closed in the “long run” with no vision as to what that term really means but the implicit threat that the public sector jobs would go very quickly indeed. His further assertion that new jobs would be created “mainly in new non-Scottish companies” misses the entire point of the argument for a reduced Corporation Tax rate — the entire proposal is intended to attract business into Scotland as well as easing the burden on existing companies. He deliberately couches the upside in woolly uncertainties whilst emphatically delineating the downside in explicit certainties.

Subjective stuff if ever there was. There's more than one way to skin a cat and surely Dr Gudgin knows that. 

There are varying degrees of what a tax rate can mean in terms of how profits are treated. Taking a straight cut off the top of all profit is the accepted way of doing things in this country and it seems that no other formula is worthy of discussion. However there are practical examples in Europe of subtle adjustments which are fundamentally pro-business and offer different opportunities. 

For instance holding companies can be permitted to be the vessels for intellectual property as long as they do not engage in commercial activity — the company holds copyright, trademark etc on behalf of commercial companies and as it is not commercially active it pays no tax. There is no coincidence here that so much copyright is lodged in Luxembourg where this is very big business indeed. So that is a scenario where a specific type of company benefits from an exemption. 

The Estonian government introduced a 0% Corporate Tax rate over a decade ago. This sounds like madness at first hearing but the reality is a 0% rate on undistributed profit. If profit is kept in the business or, even better, reinvested then the rate is 0%. If the profit is distributed as dividend, bonus or whatever then it becomes liable for taxation at regular state rates which are set on an unambiguous flat tariff. When the tax regime was introduced the nae-sayers were flabbergasted that the Corporate Tax take went UP in the first year compared to the previous system. 

The Wall Street Journal hailed the bravery and farsightedness of the Estonian government in having the guts to do something that almost every "expert" said could not work. There has been virtually no talk in the intervening years of changing the 0% system as it has attracted foreign investors and created jobs. 

A Scottish Corporation Tax based on a similar model to that of Estonia — I say similar not identical — would mark out this land as being open for business and pragmatic enough to realise that industry needs to be encouraged to grow, not flogged to death by punitive taxation. Ally that model with an enticement to lodge intellectual property in Scotland through a specific new type of holding company and all of a sudden we are firmly in the game. Maybe not quite an entrepĂ´t but certainly a modern pro-business jurisdiction.

Dr. Gudgin’s belief that new jobs will be “mainly in new non-Scottish companies” is a complete red herring as Scotland is already a cosmopolitan modern community with transnational employers well established for decades and cherished by all players in the political spectrum.

If we are to be led to believe that foreigners coming into Scotland to create jobs for Scottish workers is suddenly a bad thing then, quite frankly, the Unionist arguments have just plumbed new depths of contempt by trying to legitimise this economic pseudo-science.

dreamhost coupons